The quality that i usually expect with loreal just wasn't there. It one sweep shadow would have been an excellent idea if it had been properly executed. The colors were nice but there was no pigmentation and the applicator was a no go firstly because no 2 eyes are shaped the same so to have a universal shadow applicator was ridiculous. I attempted to use this with my regular makeup brushes but the strips of color are entirely to thin to make that work.
I almost enjoyed the mascara. It was a great formula on the black base coat but the shimmer eye enhancer could use some work.
FYI; I received these products for free in exchange for my honest review. Im a bzzagent. All opinions are mine and mines alone.